For the past three years, a team of UVA researchers has explored a question with direct implications for democracies around the world: How can capitalism interact with a country’s political systems?
The first step toward answering that question was defining “capitalism” as a system that privileges the ability to deploy capital in open markets as freely as possible, while minimizing constraints from both public and private sources.
The next step was figuring out how to measure it. The result is the new Global Capitalism Index (GCI), a first-of-its-kind dataset developed by scholars at the Karsh Institute of Democracy’s Democracy and Capitalism Lab and UVA Darden’s Institute for Business in Society.
The GCI scores 170 countries from 2009 to 2025 across eight measures of capitalism—from property rights to labor market openness. Data will be updated on an annual basis.
Under the index’s 1 to 100 scoring framework, the top country in 2025 was Switzerland at 96.6, followed by the United States at 95, Hong Kong at 94.5, Canada at 93.8, and Singapore at 93.3.
Designed to examine how capitalist conditions relate to democracy, corruption, human well-being, and equality, the interactive website allows users to select topics, datasets, and countries for customized comparisons.
“Using a large number of datasets, the goal of our project is to understand not just whether a country is ‘capitalist,’ but how it performs across different dimensions of capitalism,” said Scott C. Miller, a Darden professor and the lab director of the Democracy and Capitalism Lab. “Different countries excel in different areas, so it’s not binary.”
“The goal of our project is to understand not just whether a country is ‘capitalist,’ but how it performs across different dimensions of capitalism.”
The GCI team built the index explicitly to move debates about democracy and capitalism forward by providing researchers a way to examine where and how the two systems reinforce—or come into tension with—each other. Countries that score well on the GCI also tend to rank highly on leading measures of democratic health.
But the relationship is neither causal nor uniformly positive. The index also creates a way to examine where features of capitalist economies may come into tension with democratic values, including through inequality, concentrations of economic power, or disparities in opportunity.
“We found that capitalism and democracy are mutually reinforcing,” Miller said. “If democracy breaks down, capitalism breaks down soon after—and vice versa.”
Government Isn’t the Enemy of Capitalism—It’s a Foundation
Another finding with implications for democracies across the world is that capitalism requires not a severe reduction of government, but well-functioning public institutions. “You need courts to protect property rights and institutions to prevent cronyism and ensure that markets are competitive,” Miller said. “Those are just two types of government involvement that are necessary for capitalism to function.”
That framing matters for democracies grappling with how much regulatory and institutional capacity they need. “Government can and does get in the way of well-functioning capitalist systems,” he added, “but the idea that capitalism is simply the absence of institutions is a myth.”
Americans often view countries like Denmark as socialist rather than capitalistic, Miller pointed out, because of their robust social safety nets. The GCI tells a different story. Denmark ranked among the most capitalist nations measured, with Sweden and Norway also in the top 10. One takeaway from the GCI might be that significant social programs and investment can be consistent with highly capitalist countries, which helps explain how Denmark, Sweden, and Norway post high marks on the index despite their high tax rates.
Significant social programs and investment can be consistent with highly capitalist countries, which helps explain how Denmark, Sweden, and Norway post high marks on the index despite their high tax rates.
“Capitalism looks different in Denmark than in Switzerland or the United States, but the argument is that they are no less capitalist,” Miller said. “In fact, the Nordics are becoming more capitalist while the rest of the developed world is becoming less.”
The findings complicate the idea of capitalism as a single economic model. Countries can combine strong market systems with very different approaches to taxation, social spending, regulation, and the role of government.
Case Studies in Democracy and Capitalism
The GCI’s case studies make the democracy connection concrete. One example was the Gambia, where property rights protections shifted following the fall of a longtime dictator in 2017, offering a snapshot of how political change can coincide with movement in a country’s capitalism score.
Another case study examines Lebanon, where a banking collapse tracked in real time alongside a broader institutional breakdown in the country illustrated how economic and political fragility can move together.
China also resists an easy label. The GCI placed it in the top tier for new business formation, banking stability, and market competition, but near the bottom worldwide for property rights and free trade.
“For individual countries, the index makes it much easier to identify what conditions are conducive to capitalism and which are not,” Miller said. “Using China as an example, we can see in sharper relief the profile and shape of the underlying economy, including surprisingly strong business conditions but an increasingly restricted flow of goods and capital.”
Miller was careful to note that the GCI isn’t meant to settle ideological debates, but to give policymakers, business leaders, and citizens a rigorous, transparent tool. He emphasized that a high GCI score is not itself a judgment about a country’s broader social or political health. Rather, the index is intended to make capitalism measurable in a way that allows researchers to test its relationship to other outcomes, including democracy, inequality, and human well-being.
A high GCI score is not itself a judgment about a country’s broader social or political health but is intended to make capitalism measurable.
“We have put out a comprehensive theory that represents capitalism in a technically robust way,” he said. “That allows us to examine how capitalism translates to the broader health of society.”
As countries navigate trade tensions and question the durability of their institutions, the GCI offers a common, measurable starting point for examining how economic and political systems interact.
“This is not just an academic project,” Miller added. “The GCI can have real-world implications for policymakers and business leaders in terms of understanding the upsides and downsides of decisions. The data show that elements of capitalism appear to have an important relationship to democracy. In the long run, I don’t think you can sustain one without the other.”